PDA

View Full Version : This lady died under a con doctor's surgery to cure her stammering.


Maverick
06-11-2004, 01:32 PM
She hoped to live the doctor dream

Express News Service

New Delhi, June 7: THE white coat and stethoscope were her passion and Rinki Kumari was studying hard to wear them one day. Father Ram Pujan Singh realises the irony — that his daughter who wanted to be a doctor died on a quack’s ‘operation table’.

‘‘Rinki would speak so passionately about being a doctor that I was convinced to pay Rs 900 for her private tuitions a month,’’ said Singh, a Class IV employee of Bharat Petroleum.

On Saturday, the 16-year-old prepared dinner for the family of five before stepping out for what ‘‘doctor’’ Brij Bihari Prasad had described as a two-minute surgery to cure her stammering. Serving tea to her mother and aunt, Rinki had said she would be back by the time dinner was laid.

‘‘Kuch nahin kaha mujhko, bas itna ki mein aa rahi hoon (She just said she would be back soon),’’ said Mayadevi, Rinki’s mother.

Singh regrets agreeing for the operation in the Mahaveer Enclave clinic. ‘‘She wouldn’t stammer so much, but just like all parents we wanted Rinki to be perfect,’’ he said. On May 30, Rinki had visited Prasad with her father after a stomachache. It was there that Prasad suggested surgery for the stammering. He asked for Rinki’s blood and urine examination.

‘‘When we went back on June 5, Prasad gave Rinki three injections and asked me to wait outside the room. I couldn’t see what was happening inside but the operation took some 15 minutes,’’ said Singh. ‘‘Later, I panicked when Rinki did not regain consciousness. But Prasad kept saying all was well.’’

With Rinki not recovering, Prasad accompanied Singh and Rinki to DDU Hospital. ‘‘The DDU doctors said Prasad’s dosage was high,’’ said Singh.

Singh, however, would still give Prasad the benefit of doubt. ‘‘We have been visiting him for about a year for common ailments such as cough and cold. His medicines worked,’’ said Singh. Asked if Prasad’s medical credentials had been checked, he said: ‘‘I trusted the two boards describing him as an MBBS doctor.’’

Prasad used to charge Rs 35 for a visit. ‘‘Had I known he was a quack, I would have taken Rinki to a good doctor,’’ said Singh.


http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=86885

Maverick
06-11-2004, 01:35 PM
For every doc in city there's a killer quack

TIMES NEWS NETWORK[ TUESDAY, JUNE 08, 2004 01:30:13 AM ]

NEW DELHI : For every registered medical practitioner in Delhi , the city reportedly has more than one illegal practitioner, waiting to hack patient's tongues or to bore holes in their GI-tract in the name of an abortion.

This figure is according to unofficial estimates. There are no official figures available for the total number of quacks in the city.

The Delhi government, despite repeated instances of the perils that quacks functioning in the city pose for hapless citizens, is yet to carry out a comprehensive review regarding the number of such fake "doctors". The proposed Anti-Quackery Bill too is hanging fire.

Health minister Yoganand Shastri, even while expressing his "concern" over the reports on how a quack in Dabri area had mutilated a 15-year-old girl's tongue while trying to "cure" her stammering, admitted: "There is nothing concrete happening in the Anti-Quackery Bill front. All that I can say at the moment, is that the bill is under consideration."

According to figures available with the Delhi Medical Association, about 25,000 MBBS doctors are registered with the Delhi Medical Council, another about 4,000 Ayurvedic practitioners are registered with the Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad and about 1,000 others are registered with the Homeopathy board.

Dr Anil Bansal, ex-president, DMA, said: "By conservative estimates, and by extrapolating from a sample survey done two years back, the number of fake doctors in the city is about 40,000. That makes more than one fake doctor for every one genuine doctor. The state government has been, since November, talking of taking the Bill forward, but with two back-to-back elections, nothing was done."

Outlining the damage done by quacks, Dr Bansal talked of a case some years back in east Delhi where a quack, trying to perform an abortion through the administration of a drip, had killed the patient and in panic, he locked his chamber and fled. The body was discovered after three days when stench pervaded the neighbourhood.

An interesting phenomenon in this quack "business" is that a large number of their patients come for abortions. Dr Bansal said: "Because of the social stigma, people balk from going to reputed places. For the quacks it makes sense to say that they "specialise" in abortions because if anything goes wrong, chances of the patient or her family lodging a complaint, is the least."

Delhi Medical Council has started prosecution against 21 fake doctors in the past year. Dr S K Khattri, registrar and secretary, DMC, said, "In three of these cases, the court has taken cognizance of the offence and the verdict is expected soon. But we have no figures regarding such doctors. We can take action only if we receive a complaint."

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/cms.dll/html/uncomp/articleshow?msid=725184